Why Most Member Experience Goals Fall Short and What Credit Unions Can Do Differently

Guest Editorial by Rebecca Secor, Chief Experience Officer of Member Loyalty Group

Credit unions are not short on member feedback. Between surveys, Net Promoter Scores, satisfaction metrics and digital experience data, most organizations have more insight into the member experience than they even know what to do with it.

Rebecca Secor, Chief Experience Officer of Member Loyalty Group.

Yet for many, the results do not reflect that investment. Scores plateau, improvements feel incremental, and teams begin to question whether the metrics themselves are driving meaningful change.

The issue is not a lack of data, but how that data is translated into goals and ultimately into action.

Where Member Experience Goals Go Wrong

One of the most common challenges credit unions face is relying too heavily on a single metric. Net Promoter Score (NPS), for example, is widely used and valuable as a measure of overall loyalty, but on its own, it offers limited guidance on what to improve or how to improve it.

Another issue is how goals are set. Many organizations establish targets based on round numbers or incremental increases without fully considering historical performance or natural variation in the data. Missing a target by a fraction of a point can feel like failure, even when the underlying experience has not meaningfully changed.

There is also often a disconnect between organizational goals and what teams can actually influence. A front-line employee cannot control pricing or policy decisions, yet those factors can heavily impact overall loyalty scores. When metrics are misaligned with day-to-day responsibilities, engagement suffers.

Finally, too many programs focus on lagging indicators alone. By the time a shift appears in overall loyalty, the opportunity to address the root cause has often passed.

What Better Goal Setting Looks Like

Credit unions that see stronger results tend to approach member experience goals differently, including recognizing that not all metrics serve the same purpose and that the most effective programs balance long-term outcomes with short-term signals.

Leading indicators, such as Overall Satisfaction or Member Effort Score, provide immediate and actionable feedback, helping teams identify friction points, improve specific interactions and respond quickly to member needs. By contrast, lagging indicators like Relationship NPS reflect the cumulative impact of those efforts over time. When combined, these metrics give a more complete picture and allow teams to act with intention.

Effective programs also align goals to strategic priorities and specific initiatives, making them feel relevant and easier to act on. A credit union focused on growing its loan portfolio might set targets around reducing friction in the application process, whereas another one expanding into new markets may focus on ensuring a consistent branch or digital experience.

Ownership and role-based alignment are equally important. Executives may track overall loyalty, while branch leaders focus on satisfaction at the point of service and digital teams monitor effort within specific channels. Each group is accountable for outcomes within its control, but all contribute to the same broader objective.

The most successful programs set goals that are both ambitious and realistic, taking into account historical performance, expected variability and upcoming changes, such as system conversions or new product launches. This creates a framework that motivates teams without setting them up for frustration.

Why It Matters More Than Many Realize

Improving how goals are set leads to better measurement and has direct implications for growth and financial performance. Data comparing credit unions by member loyalty levels shows a clear pattern, with loyalty leaders consistently outperforming their peers across several key financial metrics.

Loyalty-leading credit unions have surpassed the industry’s 75th percentile in member growth across much of the past decade, driven in part by higher referral rates and stronger member retention. In fact, institutions with stronger loyalty are more likely to retain members over time, while one in four members at low-performing institutions indicate they are unlikely to stay.

They also tend to see deeper product relationships. Members who trust their credit union are more likely to expand beyond a single product, leading to stronger loan growth, higher checking penetration and greater credit card participation.

Together, these trends reveal that loyalty encompasses how members feel, how they behave, how many products they adopt, and how central the credit union becomes in their financial lives.

Over time, these differences translate into measurable financial outcomes, including higher net income per member and return on assets. When members stay longer and engage more, relationships become more stable and growth more sustainable.

Unfortunately, many credit unions treat goals as a reporting exercise rather than an ongoing discipline, which loses sight of the connection between experience and performance.

To get more value out of their member experience programs, credit unions should be using their data more intentionally, starting with setting goals that reflect both what the organization is trying to achieve and what teams can influence day to day.

When goals are clear, aligned and actionable, they give teams direction. When they are tied to outcomes that matter, they gain credibility. And when they are supported by consistent measurement and follow-through, they become a driver of both member loyalty and financial success.

Credit unions have long understood the importance of relationships. The opportunity now is to manage those relationships with the same level of precision and intention applied to other areas of the business. By balancing immediate feedback with long-term outcomes, credit unions can drive stronger growth, deeper engagement and more durable performance over time.

---

Rebecca Secor is Chief Experience Officer of Member Loyalty Group, a provider of member experience analytics and strategic support exclusively for credit unions, including the Link Between Member Experience and Financial Performance report.