New Cornerstone Advisors Survey Suggests: FIs Need to Ramp Up Their Small Business Relationship Game or Lose Out to Fintechs

By W.B. King
Nearly 75% of businesses would consolidate more financial activity with their primary bank or credit union if it matched the capabilities of the fintech provider they value most. This was a takeaway from Cornerstone Advisor’s latest report, The New Job of the Business Checking Account: Reconnecting the Workflows That Power Small Business Relationships.

Commissioned by Fiserv and authored by Cornerstone’s Chief Research Officer Ron Shevlin, the report surveyed 1,011 U.S. business owners and executives responsible for banking and financial decisions. Respondents represented businesses with annual revenue ranging from $100,000 to $100 million across a broad range of industries, business maturities and operating models.
The Trust Factor
While community banks and credit unions remain the primary financial provider for most small businesses, Shevlin noted that fintechs have steadily captured the day-to-day workflows that drive customer engagement, operating insight and lending opportunities.
"Bottom line: The account kept the money but lost the work. Financial institutions are losing visibility into the small business workflows that increasingly occur through accounting software, payment processors, expense management platforms and other fintech applications," Shevlin said. “Their future success demands that they make the financial institution the place where the relationship is informed by the workflows that businesses rely on."
Among key report findings:
Only 1 in 10 small businesses consider a fintech to be its primary financial provider, but roughly 4 in 10 have an account with one or more fintechs.
Small businesses using fintechs spend $500 to $1,500 per month on fintech fees, subscriptions and transaction costs.
Forty-nine percent of respondents would trust their bank or credit union most to provide AI-powered financial tools for their business.
Fintechs competing for small business relationships entered the market in different ways, the report offered. “They monetize different data and solve different business problems. Lumping them together under the label ‘fintech’ obscures how they actually compete, which makes it harder for banks to respond effectively.”
The report noted five key entry points:
Payments. For millions of businesses, the first fintech relationship was accepting a card payment. Square, PayPal, Shopify and Stripe embedded themselves directly into the revenue cycle. Once they controlled payment flows, they gained something banks rarely possess: continuous visibility into sales activity. That data naturally expanded into business checking, savings, cards and lending, with underwriting based on actual payment volume rather than historical financial statements.
Spend management. Brex, Ramp and Mercury influence the market by focusing on finance teams, startups and high-growth businesses where expense management and corporate cards represented a natural point of entry. Mercury is expanding beyond startups, while Ramp continues pushing deeper into spend management and AI-driven finance operations. They demonstrate that controlling employee spending creates opportunities to control broader financial relationships.
The books. QuickBooks and BILL didn’t compete for deposits; they became the financial system of record. When a business manages invoices, expenses, receivables, payroll and cash flow inside its accounting software, the software—not the bank—becomes the first place an owner goes to understand the financial health of the business. That creates a different competitive problem. A bank promising “cash-flow visibility” is competing against an app that already generates the data.
The consumer door. SoFi and Cash App have relationships with millions of consumers who do gig work, have side hustles and are creators. These “bizumers” don’t separate their financial lives the way banks separate consumer and commercial banking. Their income, expenses, borrowing and savings often move between personal and business accounts throughout the month.
Industry expertise. Companies like Toast, Gusto and Panacea Financial specialize in a single industry’s operating model, building underwriting, payments and cash-management capabilities around workflows banks often struggle to understand. Industry specialization became their competitive moat.
Reconnecting Workflows
Banking executives, the report implored, should view business checking accounts not as a transaction vehicle but rather a relationship platform. “By connecting payments, treasury management, lending, accounting integrations and customer data, financial institutions can deliver more value without replacing the fintech tools small businesses already use.”
Fiserv’s Chief Banking Officer Matt Wilcox balanced the noted data points with a fact that the research also confirms—community banks and credit unions continue to hold the most important asset in small business banking: the primary relationship.
“The opportunity now is to reconnect the workflows happening across payments, cash flow, invoicing and lending so financial institutions can deliver more insight, more value and stronger relationships without requiring businesses to abandon the tools they already depend on,” Wilcox said.



